21 July 2009

The Douglas Test for Analytic Philosophy

Wondering what you guys think about the Douglas Test, a purported test for evaluating analytic philosophy invented by the blogger who writes Missives from Marx.

Following Mary Douglas, he points out:
A hair on my head is just a hair, but if it falls off and lands on the floor, it’s dirt. What makes it dirt is, necessarily, its involvement in a set of human relations.
Therefore, he suggests that:
...to find out if an analytic theory of truth is of any use, ask yourself what the theory makes of a claim like "The hair on the floor is dirt."
(See his entry on the Douglas Test for a more complete explanation; the author of Missives from Marx is an Assistant Professor in Religious Studies at a college in the United States.)